But let’s start at the beginning: In 2021, Taylor was a long-established veteran of the industry, and she was using all of the tools that she had learned along the way at her disposal — both as an artist and as a brand — to prove that she knew how to thrive in an ever-changing music landscape. She was also one of the few artists with the power and profile to create change in the music world. To this day it rings true: When she acts, the industry listens. In reclaiming her masters, and drawing attention to the saga surrounding it, Taylor had made a dramatic statement about the importance of artists owning their work and refusing to let others capitalise on their creativity. Sure, she was a multi-millionaire (and as of fall 2023 officially a billionaire) but in using her platform in this way, she was galvanising other, less established artists to fight for a better deal. “Hopefully […] kids with musical dreams will read this and learn about how to better protect themselves in a negotiation,” she wrote in one tweet. “You deserve to own the art you make.”
In an explosive Tumblr post Taylor described Braun’s buyout as her “worst case scenario”, accusing him of “incessant, manipulative bullying” and Scott Borchetta of betraying her trust. “Scooter has stripped me of my life’s work, that I wasn’t given an opportunity to buy,” she wrote. “Essentially, my musical legacy is about to lie in the hands of someone who tried to dismantle it.”
Things took another turn in November 2019, when Taylor announced that Big Machine and Braun were blocking her from performing old tracks at the televised American Music Awards ceremony (where she was awarded the “Artist of the Decade” award), as “they claim that would be re-recording my music before I’m allowed to”. Finally, an agreement was reached — in her performance, Taylor wore a white shirt covered in the names of her six albums released with Big Machine.
Another twist came in November 2020, when Braun sold the masters to LA investment firm Shamrock Capital in a rumoured $300 million deal. Taylor said she had been “hopeful and open to the possibility of a partnership” with Shamrock but ruled that out upon learning that “under their terms Scooter Braun will continue to profit off my old music catalogue for many years”.
Artists regularly chafe against their record label contracts. But rarely do they go through the hassle of re-recording and re-releasing old work. Taylor, though, is not the usual artist. As was often the case in the past, she separated herself from the rest of the industry with sheer level of commitment. She has always been meticulous about how her work is consumed and perceived, from the aesthetics of her album covers to the comments she makes on fan blogs. Of course, Taylor has resources many don’t, but what makes her rereleases essential are the amount of attention, thought and feeling she puts into every step of the recording and the rollout, ensuring that the sets feel less like deluxe reissues and more like near-sequels to the originals. “Nobody’s tried this kind of insane project before. I mean, it’s completely bizarre. It’s like if Paul McCartney in the 70s went back and redid…Rubber Soul.” That’s what Rolling Stone wrote in November 2021.
Taylor’s hope was to override her archival works with her new versions. “Artists should own their own work for so many reasons,” she wrote in a March 2021 Instagram post. “But the most screamingly obvious one is that the artist is the only one who really knows that body of work.” As Taylor’s Versions arrived one by one, the value of the originals diminished — given the choice, fans inevitably pick recordings that support Taylor over ones that profit Braun.
The amount of care that Taylor put into Fearless (Taylor’s Version) turned the 26-track set into a must-hear remake of the diamond-certified original, and fans embraced it as such. The full-length became the first re-recorded version of a previous No. 1 album to top the Billboard 200 albums chart upon its release, with the biggest debut week of 2021 at the time with 291,000 equivalent album units, according to MRC Data.
In the end, RED (Taylor’s Version) drove as much conversation as any of Taylor’s recent all-new studio albums. Moreover, it scored a blockbuster debut, with 605,000 first-week equivalent album units moved. More than double the amount of Fearless (Taylor’s Version). Additionally, the album also launched 26 of its tracks onto the Billboard Hot 100 – a record among female artists.
In December 2021, Billboard crowned Taylor the “Greatest Pop Star of 2021.” This marked the second time she received the honor, after 2015. No other popular artist harnessed that type of fan energy with as much passion and imagination in 2021 as her, across albums and platforms, on projects that challenged the modern music industry while still succeeding wildly within it. Even without a proper new album, Taylor sent three separate projects to the top spot of the Billboard 200 during the calendar year—the first female artist to accomplish that feat in the chart’s 65-year history. And in November, one final domino fell for Taylor’s re-recordings project when iHeartRadio announced that it would now only be playing Taylor’s Versions of her older hits from each album as they rolled out—after streaming platforms had already given them prominent placement on main pages and major playlists. In addition to the impressive sales of her re-recorded albums, the reactions from the streaming and radio worlds underlined the widespread acceptance that these new recordings had replaced the classic versions as the ones listeners would be digesting and caring about moving forward.
Taylor was making the type of moves within and outside of her music that elevated an artist from superstar to legend. Those moves are often very hard to execute but no one who had been paying attention was the least bit surprised when she stuck each landing. Wind in her hair, Taylor was there, and making it look all too easy.
For the remaining first half of 2022, Taylor dropped off the radar, presumably spending most of her time in London with then-partner Joe Alwyn. Meanwhile, the media was craving new Taylor content because her public appearances had become rare; she only appeared at select film festivals to promote her short film for “All Too Well.” It all felt like the calm before the storm. Then, just as August was coming to and end, Taylor shocked the music world by finally announcing her very well-kept secret at the 2022 MTV Video Music Awards while accepting the “Video of the Year” award for “All Too Well (The Short Film)“:
The announcement timing was quite fitting, as it arrived during her first of three shows in Nashville where she launched her career in country music. The city commemorated the occasion by lighting its famous John Sigenthaler Pedestrian Bridge purple that night.
For the launch weekend of
Speak Now (Taylor’s Version), Taylor had some tricks up her sleeve. Essentially, she threw a giant release party at her “Eras Tour” stop in Kansas City, where she added an emotional performance of “
Long Live” to the setlist and premiered a new music video for the vault track “
I Can See You.” The video stars Joey King, Presley Cash (who both appeared in the 2011 music video for “
Mean“) and her ex-boyfriend Taylor Lautner, who inspired “
Back to December.” Afterwards, Taylor surprised the crowd by bringing King, Cash, and Lautner out on stage. Infamously, Taylor Lautner surprised everyone by cartwheeling and backflipping onstage in a call back to a scene he shared with Taylor in the movie
Valentine’s Day over a decade ago.
Speak Now (Taylor’s Version) achieved first-week sales of 716,000 album equivalents in the US and over 1 million album equivalents worldwide, landing Taylor at No. 1 on the
Billboard 200. At the same time, the record made history by scoring “the biggest sales week for a re-recorded album ever” at the time, besting the first-week consumption of
RED (Taylor’s Version) in 2021. In addition, Taylor was the first living artist in nearly 60 years with four of the Top 10 on the
Billboard 200 with
Speak Now (Taylor’s Version),
Midnights,
Lover, and
folklore.
When Taylor announced in March that she was “in her Eras era”, she truly meant it. During the summer months of 2023, she gained another classic hit with “Cruel Summer”, which originally appeared on Lover back in 2019. The track originally debuted at No. 29 on the Hot 100 chart on September 7, 2019, before disappearing after two weeks. By June of this year, however, “Cruel Summer” started to have a resurgence, appearing at No. 49 and slowly climbing its way higher up the chart until it finally reached No. 1 in October 2023. Celebrating the feat with co-producer Jack Antonoff, Taylor said:
Amidst her record-breaking tour, Taylor started dating football star Travis Kelce, presuambly in August 2023. The two confirmed their budding romance in September, when Taylor showed up to support the Kansas City Chiefs tight end at a home game at Missouri’s Arrowhead Stadium. The move came months after Travis first publicly expressed interest in Taylor, after attending one of her concerts—though his plan didn’t exactly work out at the time. During an episode of his New Heights podcast (which he co-hosts with his brother, Philadelphia Eagles center Jason), he shared: “If you’re up on Taylor Swift concerts, there are friendship bracelets, and I received a bunch of them being there, but I wanted to give Taylor Swift one with my number on it,” he said. Though Taylor used to hold a meet-and-greet with fans after her concerts during her previous tours, she hadn’t been doing so during “The Eras Tour” (as she performed for three hours or longer every night). “I was disappointed that she doesn’t talk before or after her shows, because she has to save her voice for the 44 songs that she sings,” Travis said. “She doesn’t meet anybody—or at least she didn’t want to meet me, so I took it personal,” he jokes.
Soon after though, sources told Entertainment Tonight that Taylor and Travis were in the “talking” phase of their relationship and were keeping it casual given their hectic schedules. Things seemed to turn more serious once September rolled around and Taylor appeared in a VIP box at Arrowhead Stadium in Kansas City, Missouri, on Sunday next to Travis’s mother, Donna—to the surprise and delight of the entire nation. The following weeks, all anybody could and would talk about was America’s new version of a “Royal Couple”. During an interview at the Chiefs’ practice facility, Travis shared how he felt about being at the center of so much attention about his relationship with Taylor:
On October 14, Taylor and Travis shared their first public appearance as a couple on Saturday Night Live. In November, Taylor continued her “The Eras Tour” with international shows in South America, and Travis was by her side during her travels. A source told Entertainment Tonight, “Travis and Taylor are all in. The two are very into each other and are enjoying their time together but are also planning for the future. Taylor starts her international tour in November, and Travis is planning to be there to spend time with her.” The insider added that both Taylor and Travis were “very serious about their careers, and the two bond over that and want to show support for each other whenever they can.”
Fans had long speculated that
1989 would be the next album from Taylor’s catalogue to be revisited. She had teased multiple Easter egg clues to the album over time and featured the rerecorded version of her single “Wildest Dreams” in the movie
Spirit and “
This Love (Taylor’s Version)” in the season one finale of Prime Video’s
The Summer I Turned Pretty. In 2023, Taylor herself also added fuel to the fire with a subtle clue in her “I Can See You” music video. In it, Taylor escapes from a bank vault, symbolizing her attempt to reclaim her music. At the end of the video, her getaway car is shown driving toward a bridge with the sign that reads “1989 TV” sign in the center, alluding to
1989 (Taylor’s Version) being next to release.
In 2014,
1989 was a seminal moment in Taylor’s career as it marked her transition into the pop genre landscape after starting her career as a country singer-songwriter. Her fifth studio album nabbed 10 Grammy nominations, winning “Album of the Year,” “Best Pop Vocal Album” and “Best Music Video” for “
Bad Blood.” At the time, Taylor had made history by becoming the first woman to win the Grammy for “Album of the Year” twice for her solo recordings. Years later, after winning “Album of the Year” again in 2021 for
folklore, she became recognized as the only female solo artist to have won the award ceremony’s top prize three times.
Upon its release on October 27, 2023, exactly nine years after the original,
1989 (Taylor’s Version) went down in history books as giving Taylor her best first week tally for an album ever. The release topped the
Billboard 200 with 1.653 million equivalent album units. That put it ahead of her previous personal best, which was 1.578 million for
Midnights. Needless to say, among the Taylor albums this one performed better than in its first week is the original
1989—which bowed nine years ago with a then-astonishing 1.297 million units.
As the entire world witnessed in real time, in wonder and awe, Taylor reached a new level of superstardom that year. She saw consistent streaming lifts throughout the year, particularly around the enormous success of “The Eras Tour.” The week the tour kicked off in March, Taylor’s streams grew 61 percent globally. She continued to see double-digit growth in monthly streams throughout the summer:
The “Eras Era” — an event so culture-engulfing it turned songs from her past into some of the biggest of that year. And Taylor Swift into Pop Culture itself.