Fearless (Taylor's Version)

STARTING THE RE-RECORDINGS WITH FEALRESS
Taylor’s decision to start the rerecording process not with her debut, but its 2008 successor seemed telling. Her debut went seven-times platinum in the US, but her songwriting came into sharp focus on “Fearless”, revealing an 18-year-old who could not only knock out indelible melodies and choruses with the efficiency of a Nordic pop factory but who also wrote lyrics that spoke directly to a teenage audience. “Deciding on what album to rerecord first was pretty easy for me,” Taylor shared in an audio clip from her record label. “I always gravitated towards ‘Fearless’ because I think that, as an album, it was a real coming of age, and I look back on that album and I just — it fills me with such pride. It was an album about hope and lessons learned and the effervescence of teenage youth and all that, so what more fun than to go back and explore that.”

“Fearless”  — be it the 2008 or 2021 version — deals in wistful reminiscence about female adolescence. Its best writing offers a brilliant fixing of the understandable teenage impulse to mythologize the recent past, to carry on as if it’s ancient history, because teenage lives are in constant flux and forward motion, packed with events that invite nostalgia because they can only happen once. As a result, “Fearless” is the kind of album in which fans have always had a genuine emotional investment:

“Before anything else, let me just say that it was a real honour to get to be a teenager alongside you. And for those of you I’ve come to know more recently than 2008, I am ecstatic that I’ll get to experience a bit of that feeling with you – now that I can fully appreciate it in its whimsical, effervescent, chaotic entirety.” – Taylor Swift

If you wanted to construct a narrative of a beloved female artist pouring her heart and soul into work that resonated with her audience versus the dead-eyed male music-industry operatives interested in nothing but money, “Fearless” was a very smart place to start.

DIFFERENCES BETWEEN ORIGINAL AND TAYLOR’S VERSION
Listening back to the whole “Fearless (Taylor’s Version)” album has a similar effect to reading back an old diary – especially as these songs are steeped in nostalgia given the prominence on first release. Taylor both celebrates and stays true to her “Fearless” era. The labor involved in this level of meticulous replication is difficult to fathom. The arrangements, this time performed mostly by Taylor’s longtime touring band “The Agency” as opposed to the original session musicians, are near-perfect facsimiles of the first cuts, down to the last twang. Taylor never cringes away from her younger self. Instead, she revisits the songs with kindness and affection, celebrating the success of her teenage releases. She told People:

“In terms of production I really wanted to stay loyal to the initial melodies that I had thought of for these songs. But if there was any song where we could improve upon the sonic quality of it, we did. I did go in line by line, and listened to every single vocal and think, ‘What are my inflections here?’ If I could improve upon it I did. I really did want this to be very true to what I initially thought of and what I had initially written – but better. Obviously.” — Taylor Swift

All the previously released songs were co-produced by Taylor and Nashville-based Christopher Rowe, who worked on some remixes during the “Fearless” era but was not the album’s original producer. Nathan Chapman, who did handle the original mixes, did not return. That didn’t seem to matter. Throughout the whole album, banjos are crisper, guitars are fuller, drums are heavier, and Taylor’s strong 31-year-old voice leads the music. The changes made to beloved tracks like “You Belong With Me” and “Love Story“, simply made them shinier. Clearly taking care to not step over her 19-year-old self, all the changes feel totally natural, like they should’ve been that way to start with. Overall, you can hear the drive. You can hear exactly what Taylor was thinking as she strived to re-make “Fearless”, but better, if she was going to be forced to sacrifice the original record.

FROM THE VAULT
“Fearless (Taylor’s Version)” features 26 songs, consisting of all the tracks from the “Fearless [Platinum Edition]” (2009), as well as her 2010 soundtrack single “Today Was A Fairytale“. And then we get to the vault. Releasing six previously unheard songs that were penned as she was writing “Fearless”, Taylor took on a unique challenge of playing with her 12-year-old drafts:

“These are songs that I’m calling ‘from the vault,’ and I call them that because there are songs that I wrote over the course of my career that were meant for certain albums, but didn’t end up making the track list for reasons that, to me, don’t really matter now. Artists should own their own work for so many reasons, but the most screamingly obvious one is that the artist is the only one who really *knows* that body of work. For example, only I know which songs I wrote that almost made the ‘Fearless’ album. Songs I absolutely adored, but were held back for different reasons (don’t want too many breakup songs, don’t want too many down tempo songs, can’t fit that many songs on a physical CD). I think curating an album is really important, but at the same time, it’s really fun to go back and show the fans the full picture of what I had created at that time. The new version is the whole story, the entire vivid picture…. the entire dreamscape that is my ‘Fearless’ album.” — Taylor Swift

Leaning into all her influences, the vault tracks range from catchy country pop on “Mr. Perfectly Fine“, to more folklore- esque minimalism on “We Were Happy“. With no original to re-create, these tracks were a perfect collaboration between Taylor’s old and new self, building something bigger around the core of her old lyrical style as sweet country phrasing was bedded within a more complex musical background where her recent indie accolades came into play. The vault provided a space for her then recent sound, with “You All Over Me” having big radio potential and “Bye Bye Baby” rounding off the defiant album with an apt message; “Bye, bye, to everything I thought was on my side”.

CRITICAL RECEPTION
“Fearless (Taylor’s Version)” was met with universal acclaim upon release, achieving a score of 82 on Metacritic, and thereby surpassing the original album’s score of 73. The Independent‘s Alexandra Pollard praised the album’s nostalgia, faithfulness to the 2008 record, and the addition of “oddly comforting” vault tracks. Saloni Gajjar of The A.V. Club wrote that “Fearless (Taylor’s Version)” showcased Taylor’s mature vocals and “sharp sense of musicianship and instrumentation”, describing it as a “mellifluous upgrade to an already remarkable album”. Will Hodgkinson of The Times said “Fearless (Taylor’s Version)” was “a masterclass in classic Nashville songwriting”, a “sweet, nostalgic” and “wholesome” record that documents Taylor’s coming of age. Alexis Petridis of The Guardian wrote that it emanates “wistful reminiscence about female adolescence”, with “a brilliant fixing of the understandable teenage impulse to mythologise the recent past, to carry on as if it’s ancient history”.

COMMERCIAL PERFORMANCE
“Fearless (Taylor’s Version)” garnered the biggest opening day for an album on Spotify in 2021, tallying more than 50 million global streams in its first day on the platform. Its tracks claimed the top ten spots of Apple Music’s global country songs chart. Fourteen tracks from the album charted on the Billboard Global 200 chart, with 8 inside the top 100. In the US, the album reached No. 1 on the US Apple Music chart, making Taylor the first female country artist to top it. It became her ninth consecutive album to open atop the Billboard 200, earning 291,000 album-equivalent units, recording the biggest opening week since Taylor’s own “evermore” (2020). In that week, “Fearless (Taylor’s Version)” sold 179,000 pure copies in the country, marking the biggest sales week and biggest first-week sum of 2021; the album accumulated 143 million on-demand streams, marking the biggest weekly streams for a country album by a female artist in the US, surpassing the former record of 24 million streams by Maren Morris’ “Girl” (2019). Topping Billboard Top Country Albums as well, the album scored Taylor her sixth No. 1 on the chart, her first since “RED“(2012). Nine tracks charted simultaneously on the all-genre Hot 100 chart dated April 24, 2021, alongside “willow” (2020). It extended Taylor’s record for the most total Hot 100 entries among women, with 136. Aided by “Fearless (Taylor’s Version)”, Taylor returned to the No. 1 spot of the Billboard Artist 100 chart for a record-extending 47th week at the surmount.

“Fearless (Taylor’s Version)” is the first ever re-recorded album to reach No. 1 in the US. With “folklore”, “evermore” and “Fearless (Taylor’s Version)” all topping the Billboard 200 in less than nine months, Taylor became the first female artist to have three different albums top the chart in less than a year, surpassing Donna Summer’s record of 14 months in 1980. The four-month gap between “evermore” and “Fearless (Taylor’s Version)” also broke Taylor’s own record for the shortest gap between number-one albums by a woman on the chart.

CELEBRATING AND RECLAIMING THE PAST
Managing to find a purpose beyond a legal battle, “Fearless (Taylor’s Version)” became a moment of reflection and celebration for both Taylor and her fans, coming together to look back on youth from the other side 13 years later.  In an industry that’s so obsessed with never-ending youth, releasing a re-recorded album where the only major difference is the age of her voice, “Fearless (Taylor’s Version)” was a powerful message about her place and longevity in this industry. Previously talking about female celebrities being “discarded in an elephant graveyard by the time they’re 35”, Taylor was shrugging off the pressure to always move forward. Instead, she re-applied her seemingly endless passion for making music to her old self, collaborating with her past in order to save it. The result: bittersweet magic that had millions feel nostalgic.